Strange Territory

This will be the first Valentine's Day that I will have a real boyfriend. Well a few years ago I had a BF on Valentine's day but we didn't do anything. He "fell asleep" really early. But anyway Stephen actually wants to spend the day with me and exchange gifts and the whole deal. But this is unfamiliar territory for me. I have no idea what do get him or do or anything. It's Christmas all over again, except worse cause this time I looked at the website "perfect gifts for nice Jewish boys" for ideas. He is not Jewish. Why can't he eat sweets? I would get him the cheesecake of the month club. Or maybe I should get him the follow your heart compass. You don't think he would be interested in a personalized yamaka, do you?